The Secret in Their Eyes(2009)
8.2 IMDb89% RT
MysteryThrillerDrama
7 Movies to Watch Next
The Body(2012)
7.6 IMDb
Amazon Prime VideoAmazon Prime Video with Ads
Like The Secret in Their Eyes for its mystery and thriller elements
Cape Fear(1991)
7.3 IMDb77% RT
AMC+ Amazon ChannelPhilo
Like The Secret in Their Eyes for its drama and thriller elements
Basic Instinct(1992)
7.1 IMDb56% RT
fuboTVParamount Plus PremiumParamount Plus Essential
Like The Secret in Their Eyes for its mystery and thriller elements
God's Crooked Lines(2022)
7.1 IMDb
NetflixNetflix Standard with Ads
Like The Secret in Their Eyes for its drama and mystery elements
Bad Boys for Life(2020)
6.5 IMDb76% RT
fuboTVYouTube TV
A strong thriller pick for fans of The Secret in Their Eyes
A Widow's Game(2025)
6.2 IMDb
NetflixNetflix Standard with Ads
Like The Secret in Their Eyes for its mystery and thriller elements
Bone Lake(2025)
5.7 IMDb83% RT
NetflixNetflix Standard with Ads
Like The Secret in Their Eyes for its mystery and thriller elements
Looking for something else? Browse more mystery movies
Search all Mystery movies →Data updated March 2026