Shutter Island(2010)
8.2 IMDb69% RT
DramaThrillerMystery
6 Movies to Watch Next
Witness for the Prosecution(1957)
8.4 IMDb100% RT
Amazon Prime VideoMGM Plus Roku Premium ChannelAmazon Prime Video with Ads
Like Shutter Island for its drama and mystery elements
The Curious Case of Benjamin Button(2008)
7.8 IMDb72% RT
fuboTVParamount Plus PremiumParamount Plus Essential
A strong drama pick for fans of Shutter Island
The Invisible Man(2020)
7.1 IMDb
PeacockYouTube TVUSA Network
A strong thriller pick for fans of Shutter Island
Stonehearst Asylum(2014)
6.8 IMDb53% RT
Amazon Prime VideofuboTVAmazon Prime Video with Ads
Like Shutter Island for its mystery and thriller elements
The Good Nurse(2022)
6.8 IMDb74% RT
Netflix
Like Shutter Island for its drama and mystery elements
The Woman in Cabin 10(2025)
5.8 IMDb28% RT
NetflixNetflix Standard with Ads
Like Shutter Island for its mystery and thriller elements
Looking for something else? Browse more drama movies
Search all Drama movies →Data updated March 2026